04 Jan

Fail: Brownie Pillow Cookies

Posted under Fail

Name: Taylor

Original Inspiration: http://pinterest.com/pin/243264817341680784/

What I Did: My boyfriend wanted pillow cookies…I think I made poison.

My Result:

Next Time I Will:  I’m giving up on Pinterest.

Comments on this post
  1. tip says:

    it would probably help to refrigerate the dough before sticking it into the oven.

    1. Colleen says:

      Parchment paper and foil are very different things, and serve different purposes when baking. I would probably have baked the cookies right on the pan if I did not have parchment paper on hand.

      1. Martha says:

        A lot of the time for “special cookies” like these and the cookie-cups made on muffin tins, people are using a regular chocolate-chip cookie recipe. That type of cookie is what my grandma called a spreader cookie. It would always spread out a little to a lot more than the original size. For specialty cookies, you can’t use that kind of dough. It’s best to use Christmas/sugar cookie dough. It spreads out a lot less and will hold its form, especially if you refrigerate it (like tip said) for at least an hour.

        1. Courtney says:

          They still look like pillows! Like pairs of boob pillows, but flat… Right, you guys??

          1. Jenna says:

            Ha! They do look like boob pillows!

Leave a Comment